Sending from your main domain
What it looks like. Cold emails go out from the same domain you use for customers, invoices and your team.
Why it hurts. Spam complaints and bounces damage that domain’s reputation, and your everyday email starts landing in spam too.
Do this instead. Use separate sending domains and mailboxes for outreach, so your main domain stays clean.
Skipping authentication and warm-up
What it looks like. New mailboxes start sending at full volume on day one, without SPF, DKIM and DMARC set up.
Why it hurts. Email providers treat new, unauthenticated senders with suspicion, so messages go to spam before anyone sees them.
Do this instead. Set up SPF, DKIM and DMARC, warm new mailboxes up gradually, and keep daily volumes modest.
Buying a big list
What it looks like. Thousands of contacts bought or scraped in one go and loaded straight into a sequence.
Why it hurts. Bought lists are full of the wrong companies, people who have left and addresses that bounce, which hurts deliverability.
Do this instead. Build a smaller list from your ideal customer, research each account, and check it by hand before anything is sent.
Faking personalisation with AI
What it looks like. A line about the prospect’s recent post or company news, generated automatically and pasted above a standard pitch.
Why it hurts. People recognise it at once, and it starts the relationship with something that isn’t true.
Do this instead. Personalise the reason you’re writing: a real problem companies like theirs face, or a specific trigger. If you can’t find a real reason, don’t send.
Pitching in the first message
What it looks like. The first email asks for a 30-minute call to present your services.
Why it hurts. Strangers rarely agree to a sales call from a cold message. A big ask makes it easy to ignore you.
Do this instead. Open with something useful or a sharp question about a problem they likely have, and make the first reply easy.
Following up with “just checking in”
What it looks like. Follow-ups that repeat the first message or only ask whether they saw it.
Why it hurts. Each empty follow-up teaches the reader to ignore you.
Do this instead. Make every follow-up add something: a short example, a useful resource or a different angle. Stop after a few touches.
Judging campaigns by open rates
What it looks like. Success is measured by how many people opened the email.
Why it hurts. Privacy features in modern email apps make open rates unreliable, and opens don’t pay the bills.
Do this instead. Track positive replies, meetings booked and the pipeline that follows. Those are the numbers that matter.
Letting replies sit
What it looks like. Interested replies land in a shared inbox and wait days for someone to answer.
Why it hurts. Interest fades fast. A slow reply to a positive response wastes everything that went into getting it.
Do this instead. Route replies to one owner, answer the same day, and hand interested people straight to a booking link and your CRM.
Ignoring the rules
What it looks like. No way to unsubscribe, no business address and no thought about privacy law.
Why it hurts. It damages trust and can break the law. Under the US CAN-SPAM Act, commercial emails need a working opt-out and a postal address, and in the EU and UK, GDPR and e-privacy rules apply to how you collect and use contact data.
Do this instead. Include a clear opt-out and your business address in every message, honour opt-outs promptly, and only contact people with a genuine business reason. Check the rules for each country you target; this isn’t legal advice.
Scaling before it works
What it looks like. Volume is increased to fix low reply rates.
Why it hurts. Sending more of something that doesn’t work multiplies the damage to your domains and your reputation.
Do this instead. Test with small batches, change one thing at a time, and scale only once replies and meetings come in steadily.
What good outreach looks like
A narrow list of companies that fit, a clean sending setup, a message about a real problem, follow-ups that add something, and replies answered the same day. On recent projects that approach lifted positive replies for Aryze from about 8% to about 22%, and brought Kuuk 22 qualified leads from 80 chosen companies in eight weeks.
Take the six-question self-check